Bitcoin Sell‑Off Pushes IBIT Investor Returns Into the Red, CIO Says
The steep decline in Bitcoin’s price over the weekend has erased cumulative, dollar‑weighted gains for investors in BlackRock’s iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT), the world’s largest spot‑Bitcoin ETF, according to the fund’s chief investment officer.
A rapid price dip turns profits into losses
Bitcoin’s market price slipped into the mid‑$70,000 range on Friday, a drop that coincided with a marked deterioration in the performance of IBIT, the flagship cryptocurrency‑focused exchange‑traded fund launched by BlackRock in June 2024.
Bob Elliott, chief investment officer at asset manager Unlimited Funds, shared a chart that tracks the aggregate, dollar‑weighted returns of all investors who have bought shares of IBIT. The graph shows that, as of the end of January, the cumulative return line has crossed below the zero‑percent threshold, indicating that on a dollar‑weighted basis the average investor is now underwater.
“The average dollar invested in IBIT is now in the red,” Elliott said on X. “The recent slide in Bitcoin’s price has pushed the fund’s net asset value lower, wiping out the gains that early adopters enjoyed.”
While early investors who bought in when Bitcoin was still trading near its $68,000‑$69,000 highs still sit in profit, the bulk of newer inflows—made at higher price points—have dragged the overall weighted return into negative territory.
How far the fund has come (and fallen)
IBIT’s trajectory has been dramatic. In October 2024, when Bitcoin was perched at record highs, the fund’s dollar‑weighted returns peaked at roughly $35 billion, reflecting both a surge in inflows and the rally in the underlying asset. The ETF also became the fastest vehicle to amass $70 billion in assets under management (AUM), a milestone that underscored BlackRock’s ability to bring institutional capital into the crypto space.
The fund’s fee generation illustrates that success. In October, IBIT generated roughly $25 million more in fees than BlackRock’s second‑most profitable ETF, making it the firm’s top‑earning product for the month.
However, recent data from Yahoo Finance show a consistent decline in IBIT’s net asset value (NAV) over the past several weeks, mirroring Bitcoin’s broader sell‑off. The NAV dip explains why the aggregate return curve has turned negative.
Outflows add to the pressure
The erosion of investor returns is occurring against a backdrop of widening withdrawals from crypto‑linked funds. CoinShares reported that in the week ending 25 January, digital‑asset investment vehicles saw about $1.1 billion flow out of Bitcoin‑focused ETFs alone, while total crypto‑fund outflows reached $1.73 billion—the largest weekly outflow since mid‑November 2025. Most of the money left the United States market.
CoinShares attributed the pullback to three primary factors:
- Diminished expectations of near‑term interest‑rate cuts – lower rates would have made risk‑on assets more attractive.
- Continued negative price momentum for Bitcoin – the recent slide reinforced bearish sentiment.
- Disappointment that digital assets have not yet benefited from the “debasement trade.”
The “debasement trade” refers to the positioning of capital in assets perceived as stores of value when fiat currencies are expected to lose purchasing power. Bitcoin, with its fixed 21 million‑coin supply, has long been billed as a digital counterpart to gold in this regard. Yet, unlike gold— which has maintained a year‑long uptrend and recently topped $5,400 per ounce—Bitcoin has struggled to attract the same level of defensive inflows.
What the numbers mean for investors
| Metric | Recent Figure | Context |
|---|---|---|
| IBIT AUM | $70 bn (fastest ETF to reach this level) | Launched June 2024 |
| Peak dollar‑weighted return | $35 bn (Oct 2024) | Coincided with Bitcoin’s record highs |
| Weekly Bitcoin‑ETF outflows | $1.1 bn (week to Jan 25) | Largest since Nov 2025 |
| Total crypto‑fund outflows | $1.73 bn (same week) | Indicates broader crypto pullback |
| Current IBIT NAV trend | Declining (aligned with BTC price) | Dragging aggregate returns negative |
Key take‑aways
- Investor returns have turned negative on a dollar‑weighted basis. Newer investors who entered at higher price levels are bearing the brunt of the recent price decline, while early entrants still enjoy modest gains.
- Outflows are accelerating. The $1.1 billion withdrawal from Bitcoin ETFs in a single week signals waning appetite for crypto exposure among institutional and retail investors alike.
- The “debasement trade” narrative is losing steam. Bitcoin’s failure to serve as a hedge against fiat inflation, especially relative to gold, is reducing its appeal as a defensive asset.
- BlackRock’s large position in IBIT remains a double‑edged sword. The fund’s sheer scale means that any sustained price move in Bitcoin will have amplified effects on aggregate investor outcomes.
- Future performance will hinge on Bitcoin’s price trajectory and macro‑economic cues. Should the cryptocurrency rebound above $80 k, the weighted return curve could quickly recover. Conversely, continued bearish pressure, coupled with a stable or rising interest‑rate environment, may keep the fund’s NAV depressed.
Outlook
Analysts warn that Bitcoin’s price volatility will continue to drive the performance of spot‑Bitcoin ETFs like IBIT. While BlackRock’s brand and distribution network give the fund a competitive edge, the product’s success ultimately depends on the underlying asset’s price dynamics and the broader macroeconomic backdrop.
Investors with exposure to IBIT should monitor both the fund’s NAV and the cumulative dollar‑weighted return metric, which more accurately reflects the profitability of the average shareholder. For those considering fresh allocations, the current negative weighted return may present a value‑oriented entry point—provided they are comfortable with the inherent price risk of Bitcoin.
Cointelegraph adheres to an independent editorial policy. Readers are encouraged to verify information independently.
Source: https://cointelegraph.com/news/bitcoin-sell-off-ibit-investor-returns?utm_source=rss_feed&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=rss_partner_inbound
